Hst 124 vs 147 recoil. Regardless, comparing a 147gr at 985fps vs.

Hst 124 vs 147 recoil. IDK how true that is, I dont reload. Yet many train with cheaper 115gr and carry expensive 147gr defensive rounds. Since they are both good, my advice is to find which one of the two you shoot the best. All my testing was conducted with standard, non +P loads. 147 +P 355, numbers by memory but within a ballpark. Oct 19, 2015 · In 45 it's 230 grain, standard pressure HST for my Champion Operator. Jan 7, 2010 · 124 +p = +200 to +250fps over 147gr "Experienced" or "felt" recoil can be subjective. Hst 124 or 147 is the choice. Did one perform better than the other? Dec 3, 2017 · I have several boxes of the 147 HST but I prefer the feel of the recoil from the 124 HST (both standard pressure). 124 or 147 are both great, but in my experience barrels under 4" seem to prefer the 147 as far as accuracy. . I thought of going down to 124 gr for concealed carry and was considering if that should be +P. Guess which one recoils less. 147gr would be ideal. I don't know anyone who shoots a full load 147gr in competition. In a 4" barreled G19, I switched from HST 124 gr +P to standard pressure HST 124 gr. HST's will stop a threat but I love the Gold Dots. 40 loads. (They varied based mainly on light intensity). So the 124gr has 13. Today he turns his sights on Federal Premium 124-grain HST, and the results are, well – a bit of a spoiler – […] Jun 28, 2009 · I like 147Gr!! in 9mm Most tests pound for pound show 147gr. That's my advice. 124 +P HST has muzzle energy of 395 f/s. Your front sight takes longer to return. 5 inch barrel I’ll take the +p due to little higher energy and will aid In cycling if dirty conditions the +p actually penetrate deeper in all barrier testing Gary Roberts confirmed that along with tnoutdoor9 Mar 30, 2020 · 115 grain vs 124 grain vs 147 grain question. Also a 147/160 gr will shoot 1. The “Personal Defense” packaging is more expensive. 8" penetration) If I am shooting the 124, then a 147, then a 124 I can feel slightly less recoil with the 147s . I carry and train with 124 grain Federal HST ammo in my every day carry gun but I'm in the process of suppressing a 9mm carbine. Posted: 2/11/2013 12:41:04 PM EDT Apr 13, 2023 · Left to right, if were carrying the Federal 124-grain Hydra-Shok, the Federal 124-grain HST, or Speer 124 grain Gold Dot, we would feel well protected. And what's a main rule of tactical training? "More hits on target. The 9mm, 124-grain HST +P load, for example, generates 366 ft. But I can promise you there is a difference in felt recoil with the 124gr HST being more snappy. HST seems easier to locate, at least for me. Any comments on recoil and ability for good follow up shots of 147 standard, 124 standard, and 124 +p. +1 on Federal HST, only round I carry with in 380, 9mm, & . Oct 11, 2013 · For target I have been using 115 and 124 gr FMJ. Only LE carry HP. Sep 3, 2016 · Not HST's but I have carried and shot 124+p Speer gold dots for a few years. Apr 12, 2010 · In 45 it's 230 grain, standard pressure HST for my Champion Operator. 124 gr HST's and Gold Dot's have a well proven track record on the street! I think that the 124 gr is the way to go with the current crop of sub-compact 9mm handguns because they rarely have feeding problems like the 147's do in some sub compacts. Recently saw an article that most people were thinking 124gr was better, faster, etc. Most self-defense encounters involve 3 to 5 rounds expended in mere seconds at a range of less than 15 feet. I use the 124 gr HST +p in my large semiauto pistols and the 147 gr HST +p in my Ruger PC9 carbine. The 124 grain plus p HST's I've been using are noticeably heavier recoiling than standard pressure rounds. Apr 24, 2019 · I used 124+P Gold Dot and 124 AE until HST became available and switched to 124+P HST. Back in 07. I come from the . aside from felt recoil of light vs. , 124, 124+p, and 147 grain bullets travel somewhat slower, stay in their flat trajectory a shorter time and then begin their drop, but generally impact the target higher only at close ranges, under 25 yards. Perceived recoil from HST +P loads is stouter. MGYSGT USMC 86-13 O331,8541, 8532, 8412. HST definitely beat Gold dot though. Even from a 4″ barrel, it’s pushing close to 1,200 FPS. Since most 147 grain ammo is subsonic, it would make sense to use that in a suppressed carbine. I did a wet phone book test. I am now taking a look at winchesters 147 bonded ranger. 40 cal world though, and it's still a little less recoiling than light . Added in 124 grain American Munitions JHP by AmericanReload Testing some Federal HST 9mm 124 Grain standard and +P defensive hollow point ammo using the Sig P365!Join this channel to become a member of The Range Gang: Sep 3, 2016 · Not HST's but I have carried and shot 124+p Speer gold dots for a few years. I choose either Speer GD 124+p or Federal HST 147. 7 inch May 26, 2020 · No issues with my early pig-nose Glock 19. 40 . Sep 24, 2021 · Right now I'm running some Federal HST 147gr. After attending ballistic workshops from both manufacturers, my opinion was that the expansion and penetration were close enough that it didn't matter. However, I like the 124 better since it allows the slide and sight to come back faster for a quicker second shot compared to 147 ammo. heavy loads, bullet Oct 19, 2019 · HST 124/147 standard pressure and Gold Dot 124 standard pressure. Jul 14, 2017 · Any of the major brand 124's w/ a bonded bullet should do the trick. The HST offers an advantage in barrier penetration. As far as the price, the HST is sold in “Personal Defense” packaging, and in “Law Enforcement” packaging. That’s why lighter recoil makes it easier to direct rapid fire. the 124 +P cycles great and is accurate, but it has significant recoil compared to the 147 and my 124 Winchester FMJ Nato practice ammo. Keep in mind that ballistic testing is not true one to one with performance on a bad guy. Apr 16, 2021 · On the other hand, for me and my specific 9mm guns and the specific rounds used, I have found that heavier bullets, e. Jun 5, 2020 · Of the short barrel tests in HST - 124, 124+P, 147, 147+P - the 147+P has the most momentum. Also, the ΔV for +P in a short barrel isn't typically 50 fps - but typically about 1/2 of that. 9mm Luger Personal Defense Ammunition Testing Personally, I like 147gr loads. I reload and shoot 124/125 Gr ammo for plinking and competition. May 15, 2019 · Their 115 gr load clocks at 131-133 power factor, their 124 and 147 at about 140. 45 GAP (230). The recovered rounds looked almost identical with only the differnce in 147 to 165 gr in weight between them. Oct 31, 2018 · The 147-grain bullet features the popular HST design, which is intended as an improvement over the Hydra-Shok. And, different gun designs handle recoil differently. Feb 10, 2018 · I imagine the recoil is indeed less. 02 worth! Federal HST/Speer Gold Dot, 124+P and 147+P loads also perform well, but slightly worse the the crit duty load. 100" going about 1,080 fps. Jan 2, 2022 · Recoil is milder than the 124 grain HST standard pressure. Perhaps with a RDS, a difference might be discernible. We do not test barrier penetration, but expansion in water was very good and so was penetration. Aug 31, 2018 · The momentum formula M1V1/M2 = V2 proves the answer to the question is it depends on how fast your 115 and 147gr are going. Jul 7, 2017 · I just wanted opinions on 124 grain 9mm vs 147 grain 9mm in terms of a defensive ammo. Before anybody goes and recommends +P in either version, please don't because I am not interested. Reactions: snowbird. The HSTs are consistent (and very pretty) in expansion tests. Why? Because a 115gr, 124gr, or 147gr low recoil is more accurate in match shooting. Jan 8, 2022 · I can’t speak for 124’s, but I’ve always run 135’s or 147’s and Vitavhouri (sp) N320 powder. Feb 10, 2013 · In my opinion the 147gr bullets mean more felt recoil, and I don't notice much of a difference in recoil between the 124gr standard pressure and +P, so I use the 124gr +P version. The GD isn't bad on recoil, but long term, the HST may make me a little quicker. The more grains in a bullet (like the 147gr) the harder it will hit. I've never heard anything good about 115gr though, except like 1 round was okay in it. Generally prefer the 124 myself. While the Gold Dots definitely work, those bullets seem to expand less consistently in gel tests. Jan 25, 2014 · What’s the difference between ammo that’s lousy in a short-barrel 9mm carry pistol and ammo that works spectacularly in a short-barrel carry pistol? ShootingTheBull410’s 9mm Ammo Quest shows just how it should be done. Gel tests indicated no advantage to the +P I terms of penetration or wound cavity (just more recoil). 5"-2" higher than a 115/124 at 20 yards. 124 +P tends to over expand, even out of short barrels, limiting its penetration depth. g. Jul 7, 2020 · Recoil, also known as kick, is the force a handgun exerts back upon its user when it is fired. Because recoil flips the barrel of a handgun upward (a phenomenon called “muzzle flip”), it effectively undoes some or all of the effort the shooter put into aiming their handgun. Lighter bullets like the 115 grain will fly faster and have a flatter trajectory. with a non +p load,not bad!! Dec 30, 2019 · Practice with 115 grain, Carry 124 or 147. Dec 23, 2013 · I'd personally prefer to carry whatever HST has the least recoil, but gelatin doesnt say that, but I guess people here say 147 has less recoil than lower grain due to longer impact time. Both loads eject with authority and functioned very well through 50 rounds each. Feb 11, 2010 · To much recoil for no gain. Both rounds are undoubtedly highly effective SD rounds so the choice for me hinged on my ability to deliver fast followup shots. Apr 20, 2016 · Both the 124gr HST and 147gr HST (either standard pressure & +P) do a great job penetrating and have a good expanded diameter. I was surprised at how much more recoil I felt. Once I find enough 9mm HST in 124 grain (non +p) I may try that. Sep 5, 2016 · Not HST's but I have carried and shot 124+p Speer gold dots for a few years. Choose the 147 grain HST. So we all pretty much shoot anything except HP. 147 also has noticeably softer recoil Reactions: sharklaser Save Share By chance HST 124+P and 147, are the two 9mm JHP loads I use. 0-14. of energy at the muzzle. Regardless, comparing a 147gr at 985fps vs. This also shows that 124 is not always a compromise. Jul 26, 2002 · Of the short barrel tests in HST - 124, 124+P, 147, 147+P - the 147+P has the most momentum. American Eagle and they work great in all my 9mm pistols with slightly less felt recoil. Jan 10, 2010 · For me, 147 gr at 960-980 fps is easiest to control, followed by the 115/1,220-1,260, 124/1,150-1,200 and 127/1,233-1,260. Feb 9, 2022 · There less recoil, muzzle flip or dip with the 147 compared to the 124. 5 over 6,646 rounds since 2017, including: Federal HST 147, American Eagle 147 flat nose, AE 124 and 115, S&B 115, Lawman 147 and 115, BB 115, Speer Gold Dot 124, 124+p, Syntech 147 and 150 TSJ, etc. For defense, concealed carry I bought 147 jhp. When velocities change momentum changes, but now you're changing a variable and the formula needs to be recomputed. Excepting M&P 9mm pistols, I notice little difference in POI of impact in semi-auto pistols in 9, 40, 10 Jun 21, 2024 · 115, 124, and 147 grain 9mm ammunition are common loads to find on the shelves. There was a time, many years ago when the 147 grain hollowpoints starting appearing for the 9x19, that they were considered a joke at the least, and at most, might get you killed due to terminal ineffectiveness Those days are long gone. Both guns ate this mix of loads/brands without issue. My USPSA Minor floor (125,000) load is a 124 gr Bayou HiTeck over 4. Of course, any of the ammo will run in my Rugers, but I like standard velocity for my PF9. There still going around 1000 fps. 0 grs of TG at 1. I have fired a variety of 115, 124, and 147 grain FMJ 9X19mm (several brands) in both a P228 and a 9mm AR and honestly I could not tell the difference in recoil or muzzle flip. Mar 23, 2021 · So a 124gr going 1,000 fps will "feel" snappier than a 147 gr going 850 fps. 40 and GlockFan7. Carry 124 or 147, but not 115. The Walther PDP-F test gun provided good accuracy and faultless reliability. 147gr shoots different than 115gr. Testing two different weights of Federal HST 9mm hollow point defensive rounds using the Taurus GX4. I haven't done a whole lot of research into the 147 grainers just because of the lower ft lbs of energy. at 7 yards the 147gr is 312ftlbs 974fps vs 124gr is 354ftlbs 1134fps. But if suppression is important then use this. Jan 7, 2019 · 124gr HST performs better out of shorter bbls than the 147gr, the 124 has fed perfectly through my Shields, P320 & fullsize M&P's. It’s not as snappy as 124 nato. I know there are other good choices but these 3 do it for me in all of my 9's. I switch between 147gr Hyrda-shok (damn you gander mountain for mixing my HST order up and sending the wrong round) and Hornady Critical Duty +P. 147gr will penetrate deeper because of its mass. Gold Dot 124 +P is the best on the market hands down! The late Paul Harrell does a great youtube video demonstrating the wound channel of the Gold Dot vs the HST's and Gold Dots are superior. I use 124gr hst a quick comparison between speer gdhp 124gr 1150fps and speer gdhp 147gr 985fps. Also some Russian steel and euro ammo feels about as warm Most 115gr American loaded 9mm is pretty weak. Aug 22, 2009 · I was fortunate enough to buy both 124 gr and 147 gr HST HP, both +p. Just my . The 147 load looked real nice on paper at 7 yards, and coupled with the likelyhood its expansion threshold at lower velocities is more tolerant, I'm going with this load. I don’t like the recoil impulse of 147. +P just makes it recoil harder, don't bother. In Australia 115/124/147 all run same price. TNOutdoors9 tests with my exact gun, so I luckily can just go by his statistics. I actually did some head to head testing today using Sport Pistol powder, 135 TC Blues and 147 FP Black bullets. Short barrel test through heavy clothing. Jun 28, 2009 · I know I already have a thread I left out the 147+P however. winchester silver tips. The test is being performed out of a Sig Sauer P320 m17 9mm with a 4. My preference is the GD, but it is hard to find in stock at affordable prices. But when I did the calculations, the HST 147gr vs some Sierra 124gr that I had - the HST had more muzzle energy in the end. 45 ACP +P (230); and . The expantion was really good with the 147 GR. Those are real world velocity ranges, measured at 15 feet from the muzzle. Jun 10, 2015 · The Law Enforcement Tactical HST lineup includes 9mm and 9mm +P (124, 147), . -lbs. I use 124 grain (not +P) HST in my P365XL. Aug 20, 2020 · This is an ammunition test of 2 Federal HST 9mm rounds, the 147 and 124 grain +p. Due to age and disabilities as well as owning several small pistols I switched to 147gr. 147 recoils lower than 115 when both are loaded to the same momentum / power factor. Jun 8, 2018 · I use HST for defensive rounds. Semper Fi. Out to 25 yards, in Glock and HK pistols, I haven't noticed any difference in POI, although the 124+P has more felt recoil. The GD has a bit more zip to the recoil, but the 147 is not much different. Works as a general all round plinker and IPSC minor PF. Based on my research, the terminal ballistic performance of the +P ammunition from a small barrel like that isn't different enough from the regular 124 grain ammo to warrant the downsides of increased time between follow-up shots, costlier training ammunition to simulate the same load, increase wear on the firearm, etc. HST and 147gr. 45 ACP and . etc. Jul 2, 2020 · 124 +p load only ran 12 fps faster than the 147 (952 vs. Apr 25, 2022 · There are, however, some considerations. 40 S&W (165 and 180), . Apr 9, 2019 · To much recoil for no gain. Jul 6, 2020 · So you can use nato 124 as practice and get the exact same feel and POI. rounds penatrate better. 940). We don’t have the concept of “self defence” at all here let lone CCW. The difference between these loads is the weight of the bullet. I only use 115 gr FMJ and HP at a standard load in my PF9. Jul 30, 2012 · They both opened up perfectly, and penetrated about 14 1/2 inches as i recall. If I could have only one for all my bbl lengths, it would be the 124gr HST. Jan 29, 2019 · HST 147 "personal defense" (913 fps, 13. Comparatively (to the 147+P) the 124+p and the 147 are within +/- 1% of each other, statically and functionally no difference. When a 115 124 147 all goes the same 1,200 fps, the 115gr will recoil less. Although I carry 124 +P GDHP when I carry a 9mm, I would feel adaquate with the 147 gr HST from Federal. 9mm 124 grain HST vs 147 grain, both standard pressure. Jul 1, 2014 · In my Shield I have loaded the standard pressure 124-grain HST, with the backup magazine stoked with standard pressure 115-grain Gold Dot. I stock and shoot both in a variety of guns. I disagree with Federal HST's as the best ammo. In the handguns used for testing it wasn’t a concern, although the velocity numbers don’t lie. " You do you. The 147’s were slightly more accurate and maybe a tad softer. For the 9mm, I was curious about the HST working in a sometimes inhospitable environment: the Browning Hi Power. 115gr at any pressure, and standard pressure 124/147 loads generally perform worse in all conditions according to the data I have. Favourite at the moment is Fiocchi 124 CP LRN. 4% more ftlbs because of the extra speed the 124gr will expand faster and should have less penetration compared to the 147gr. Jan 6, 2011 · The plus 124+p hst is actually the right pressure and the standard 124 hst is on the hot side that’s why it’s not a big difference in FPS in a full size 4-4. 357 SIG (125), . If I can get a little less recoil with the standard pressure HST, it would be a plus. 124gr at 1220fps and you are talking a 33% difference in energy forward/back; I think almost anyone will notice that. Of course YMMV ETA: Both HST and Gold Dot are also my go to in 230 gr std pressure in my 45's. If a 124+P is good because it expands fast and travels at a good speed, the 147 doenst travel as fast but heavy bullet and penetrates more and expands more than the 124+P, also the 147+P is heavy and travels at a decent speed. otqu lop wuee wyqj uyoeo bqe vlc pxumuqt tswvhhfiy zvvjr